Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

7.0(2)|2026-04-23|2 seasons, 8 episodes

Mystery

Overview

After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.

Episodes

Season 1(8)Specials(1)

S1E1 · 2026-04-23 · 44m

The Buggy Before the Horse

A hidden intruder tests faith and compassion as Cheryl races to protect Sugarcreek before Thanksgiving.

S1E2 · 2026-04-30

A Season of Secrets

A vanished Amish boy, secret texts, and buried truths pull Cheryl into Sugarcreek’s most personal mystery.

S1E3 · 2026-05-07

O Little Town of Sugarcreek

Christmas thefts and a returned ex force Cheryl to protect an innocent friend and her heart.

S1E4 · 2026-05-14

Off the Beaten Path

A vanished bus, fake FBI agents, and hidden feelings test Cheryl’s courage—and her heart.

S1E5 · 2026-05-21

Simply Vanished

A hidden chute leads Cheryl to a decades-old disappearance—and a birthday she’ll never forget.

S1E6 · 2026-05-28

Stitch in Time

A mysterious quilt leads Cheryl to a buried secret—and a family ready to heal.

1 / 2

Top Cast

View All

Galadriel Stineman

Cheryl Cooper

Denise Gossett

Naomi Miller

Kevin Joy

Levi Miller

Lance E. Nichols

Chief Twitchell

Ryan O'Quinn

Seth Miller

Riley Beeson

Esther Miller - Young Naomi Miller